Add to Google

Which is better, CGI or ASP?

Pages: 1, 2
free web hosting

Read Latest Entries..: (Post #17) by Galahad on Dec 23 2004, 12:37 AM. (Line Breaks Removed)
OK, I'm not going to write anything new here, that other people didn't write already. I would also choose ASP over CGI, but only due t a fact that I'm a VB programmer, so I'm familiar with language. I myself am not a MSFT fan, but hey, it just turned out that way Anyway, ASP.NET introduced some pretty neat features, and can be safely classified as a programming language, as oposed ... read more.
Read the FIRST post of this Topic. - Express your Opinion! Contribute Knowledge :-).

Open Discussion > CONTRIBUTE > Computers > Programming Languages > VB Programming

Which is better, CGI or ASP?

zhangzy
As the title? just need your suggestions.

Reply

LuciferStar
ASP is only supported by WIN32?

Reply

GhostKillerX
i think both can do the same thing

try using php its more advanced

Reply

neeki4444
CGI is much faster than using ASP and CGI is platform independent unlike ASP where its just a microsoft technology.

Amazon.com, yahoo.com, and ebay.com write their website in C++ and cgi. Its much more efficent and faster.

Reply

zachtk8702
if im correct, I beliece CGI can be more secure. I believe that ASP is more vulnerable to SQL attakcs, which can be very threatening.

Reply

arp
CGI is a much older and much less efficient standard. the main problem with CGI is that each request fires a new process for the CGI script regardless of the language.
On the otherhand, newer technologies like ASP and JSP/Servlet and PHP execute requests as threads within the Web Server process - much more secure (re. system crashes), scaleable and efficient.
CGI is also pretty bare-bones and you got to be good at pattern-matching coding and lower-level coding, although I am sure you can find heaps of useful CGI scripts and code snippets to use.
ASP/Java/PHP all give you lots of built in features for example to handle POST data.
Now I am not exactly a big fan of ASP, I much prefer PHP or Java; but i would still choose ASP over CGI. And I am not sure about what improvements .NET has added aside from what microsoft ripped off from Java (i.e. auto garbage collection).

best regards,
- arp

Reply

eldeo
I think ASP is much better than CGI. ASP is newest than CGI, it has more options, and you can simply create big web applications (using ASP).
On the other hand, it's true that ASP is slower than CGI, but in the future nobody will use CGI

--
eldeo

Reply

MercifulFate
Well if you think about it CGI has been around for a long time. Its stood up to others time and time again and is still around to tell the tale. It's features may be a little behind for it's time but it makes up for it in stability.

ASP on the other hand I believe is better for today's world it may be a little slower then CGI but the stability is there. Its features are growing more every day.

So If I were to choose Id choose ASP.

Reply

filipc
I hate ASP because:

-It is only on win.
-Very slow !!! sad.gif

CGI is faster , CGI is better smile.gif

Reply

pweb
I think CGi is better
and Fastter

Reply

Latest Entries

Galahad
OK, I'm not going to write anything new here, that other people didn't write already. I would also choose ASP over CGI, but only due t a fact that I'm a VB programmer, so I'm familiar with language. I myself am not a MSFT fan, but hey, it just turned out that way wink.gif

Anyway, ASP.NET introduced some pretty neat features, and can be safely classified as a programming language, as oposed to ASP that is only scripting language.

And of course, depending on your needs, select CGI or ASP. There are hundreds of thousands of Perl scripts, or precompiled CGI applications on the web. But, as most of people, I would go for PHP, which is by far the greatest language ever smile.gif

Reply

spirit_valley
I'd also choose ASP since it's much easier to learn.
And since most people still use Windows, it's not a big problem when ASP is limited to Windows' products... tongue.gif

But, why don't use PHP? It's becoming more popular now.

Reply

ariya
I think CGi is better
Asp is easy but cgi is fast
learning cgi is hard but cgi is better

Reply

faceofdie
I think CGi Is better

Reply

rejected
i like cgi better

Reply



Got an Opinion! Express your Views! (no registration):-
Add your Reply/ Opinion/ Views/ Comments/ Suggestion/ Questions/ Queries etc.
Posts with decent grammar & English will be accepted and please refrain from profanities.
For asking a Question, We recommend you to sign-up (for free) so that you can track the topic easily.

Nature of your Post*: Opinion/ Reply/ Comments
Question/Query
Feedback to us.
       
Name   Email
Title/Question*

Pages: 1, 2
Similar Topics

Keywords : cgi asp


    Looking for cgi, asp






*SIMILAR VIDEOS*
Searching Video's for cgi, asp

*MORE FROM TRAP17.COM*
advertisement



Which is better, CGI or ASP?