Jul 27, 2008

48% Of Doctors Admit To Prescribing Placebos Just To Shut You Up

Free Web Hosting, No Ads > General > Health and Fitness (WellnessPostive.com) > GENERAL (health and Fitness)

free web hosting

48% Of Doctors Admit To Prescribing Placebos Just To Shut You Up

guitar22891
QUOTE
48% Of Doctors Admit To Prescribing Placebos Just To Shut You Up
According to a survey by the University of Chicago, 48% of doctors said "they have given at least one treatment when there was no evidence it would work."


Placebo treatments included vitamins, herbal supplements, saline infusions, dummy pills and doses of medicine too low to be effective. One of the most common placebo treatments was giving antibiotics for viral infections that don't respond to antibiotics. Unneeded antibiotics? Oh, what an awesome idea.

I actually caught a doctor of mine doing this. I was experiencing a crazy type of insomnia where I'd wake up every 45 minutes all night long for like, um, years. I finally decided that this was abnormal and went to the doctor to ask for some help. He said it was probably "stress" and prescribed something to take before bed. When I went to fill the prescription, the pharmacist goes, "Ok, I could fill this, but its just half of a benadryl. They're right over there on the shelf, and you can just break them in half."


Notice from rvalkass:

Anything you copy must be put in Quote tags.
http://consumerist.com/341997/48-of-doctor...-to-shut-you-up

 

 

 


Reply

Joshua
QUOTE(guitar22891 @ Jan 9 2008, 12:03 PM) *
48% Of Doctors Admit To Prescribing Placebos Just To Shut You Up
According to a survey by the University of Chicago, 48% of doctors said "they have given at least one treatment when there was no evidence it would work."
Placebo treatments included vitamins, herbal supplements, saline infusions, dummy pills and doses of medicine too low to be effective. One of the most common placebo treatments was giving antibiotics for viral infections that don't respond to antibiotics. Unneeded antibiotics? Oh, what an awesome idea.

I actually caught a doctor of mine doing this. I was experiencing a crazy type of insomnia where I'd wake up every 45 minutes all night long for like, um, years. I finally decided that this was abnormal and went to the doctor to ask for some help. He said it was probably "stress" and prescribed something to take before bed. When I went to fill the prescription, the pharmacist goes, "Ok, I could fill this, but its just half of a benadryl. They're right over there on the shelf, and you can just break them in half."


The thing is, just because doctors prescribe something when there's no evidence it will work, doesn't mean they're doing it to shut someone up. It may have been a rare case where there were no known treatments or else treatments that would normally be available for whatever reason were unavailable at the moment, and thus the doctor had to pick something he didn't know would work.

I'm not saying that's the case, I'm just saying it seems like the title is misleading from what the actual study showed.

 

 

 


Reply

kobra500
Thats bad!!! oh well never mind I hope it's not this bad in the UK i am pretty sure I've never had that happen to me but who knows... 48% and thats assuming every1 was telling thetruth (which i doubt ALOT)

Reply

Liam_CF
Woah, that's pretty bad. Your doctor should just be honest with you, not just try to shut you up. They could be damaging your health.

Reply

strange-garden
I was given placebo anti-depressants. I called the doctor 2 weeks into it and told him they weren't working, and he said to wait 3 weeks...On the 3 1/2 week I went to hospital from panic attacks. The pills were supposed to help the panic attacks.



Reply



Got an Opinion! Express your Views! (no registration):-
Add your Reply/ Opinion/ Views/ Comments/ Suggestion/ Questions/ Queries etc.
Posts with decent grammar & English will be accepted and please refrain from profanities.
For asking a Question, We recommend you to sign-up (for free) so that you can track the topic easily.

Nature of your Post*: Opinion/ Reply/ Comments
Question/Query
Feedback to us.
       
Name   Email
Title/Question*

(Maximum characters: 10,000)
You have characters left.
Confirm Code:

Similar Topics

Keywords : 48percent, doctors, admit, prescribing, placebos, shut

  1. I Hate Doctors!
    They have no clue what they are doing sometimes! (1)
  2. Stage6 Shut Down
    WTF? (3)
    I think I'm kind of late for this, but stage6.com has shut down on Feb 28th. They said it was
    too expensive or something. Just try going to Stage6 , and you'll see their long explanation of
    why they shut down. I'm not sure how many of you used it, but I loved it. It was a good place
    to find free movies, for a couple of hours before they got deleted. /biggrin.gif"
    style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":D" border="0" alt="biggrin.gif" /> They also had plenty of
    good user videos. And when you downloaded DivX, stage6 was the first place they sent you. Now t....
  3. Stupid People Who Can't Shut Up.
    I swear I'm going to kill this guy. (15)
    You know what I don't understand. . .what the whole fascination is behind this phrase: "Your
    Mom." It is honestly one of the stupidest things I've ever heard come out of anyone's mouth,
    and so many people say it after everything that it not only makes them sound stupid, but they sound
    like jerks. This mostly comes up now because one of these stupid guys in here (I'm in a
    computer lab mostly by myself except for this nasty sophomore who won't shut up!) keeps
    insisting on not shutting his bad mouth! I really couldn't care that one of the co....
  4. Argg, Shut Up, Shut Up!
    (7)
    Okay, I have a boyfriend. Yes sir, and ma'am, I adore the kid. But there are people, and I
    MEAN, a LOT of people, telling me I shouldn't be with him. Just because he smokes, and drinks.
    SO WHAT? They tell me, "I don't like him, Jen, he's not a good guy." But what about my
    opinion? I know I shouldn't even be listening to them, but jeebus, can't they just leave me
    and him alone? We don't give nobody issues, and they're stirring up drama for themselves &
    us. My friends tell me those people are haters, and shoot, I think I agree. Are....
  5. Gamefaqs.com Has Been Shut Down
    I tell you people have nothing else better to do (6)
    I went to one of my favorite websites gamefaqs.com and they got shutdown some about cheating or some
    junk like that I cannot believe here look. www.gamefaqs.com april fools ....
  6. Super-fast Start And Shutdown Windows (within Seconds)
    hibernate instead of shut down (25)
    I just wanted to share this tip for all those guyz who hate to wait for windows to boot up and load
    into memory.. And not only that, after booting, it starts loading all the startup programs into
    memory. If you are also fed up doing this, You can use the HIBERNATE option. :-) All you have
    to do is, configure your PC to use HIBERNATE instead of SHUTDOWN. About Hibernation, QUOTE
    Hibernation is a state in which your computer shuts down to save power but first saves everything in
    memory on your hard disk. When you restart the computer, your desktop is restore....
  7. Annoyingly Long Time For Shut Down
    (14)
    To begin with , there are several reasons why windows takes an excessive amount of time for shut
    down to be complete , in order to understand why this happens we must remember that windows os is
    not a single program , but rather a collection of individual services.Each of these must be stopped
    during shut down. Therefore any problem related to any of these may prolong the shut down process or
    cause a crash . A potential cause for this problem is that windows contains an option to erase the
    system's virtual virtual memory and system hibernation cache at shut down.Thes....
  8. Religious Fundamentalist's Bank Account Frozen
    ...I have to admit: Patriot Act works :/ (4)
    According to an article in The Tampa Tribune from Wednesday, the daily work of a group of
    religious fundamentalists has been severely disturbed due to actions taken according to the US
    Patriot Act about four months ago. The group's main bank account was frozen, deposits were not
    accepted and 22 checks bounced. Anonymous sources say that state agencies were involved and some
    Visa could not be paid; for unknown reasons none of the religious fundamentalists was arrested.
    ...hooray Patriot Act /smile.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":)" border="0" alt="sm....
  9. Water Shut Off But We Paid The Bill
    I am covered in soap (9)
    The water bill was dropped off at the place two days ago. I don't know what happened, but today
    when I was in the middle of a shower, shampoo in my hair and body wash from head to my knees, they
    came and shut off our water. So now I guess I am doing research on what happens to someone covered
    in dry soap. I tried to get most of it off with towels but I am sort of itchy in places. I am afraid
    to take this towel turban off of my hair. I hope there are no long term effects from having shampoo
    in your hair for who knows how long. this is really not any fun at all. We&....
  10. Will Manual Shut Down Hurt Your Pc?
    (20)
    Well what I want to know is: Will doing a manual shut down hurt your computer? Manual shut down as
    in not going to (This is on Windows XP) start menu,turn off your computer, and hit turn off. Some
    people I have talked to say it hurts your computer when you do a manual shut down. Does doing a
    manual shut down hurt your computer?....
  11. Www.freebb.com Taken Down?
    Why did they shut down? (3)
    Hey. Recently, I had noticed that the forum that my site uses has ceased to work. We used a phpBB
    board, because we preferred the setup and styles that it offered. I did not host it myself to make
    sure that I did not have extra and unnecessary bandwidth or disk space usage; we used the host
    www.FreeBB.com (a site suggested at the www.phpBB.com website). Well as it turns out, not only is
    our forum down, but it also appears that the www.FreeBB.com site is also shut down. I would reallly
    like to continue using a phpBB forum without having it hosted using my space so I ....
  12. Doctor's Becoming Robots
    (10)
    I forget what they call the robots, but they have a computer screen, camera and infra-red
    sensor's. The doctor sits in his office 30 miles away and can speak to his patients through this
    robot and they can speak back. Just by sitting in that same seat he can control where the robot goes
    and review patient history and other important documents. By keeping this method of doctory around i
    think that the amount of doctors could become minimised because one doctor could serve to a whole
    heap of patients through this new technology. though you would still need doctors that....
  13. Does Your Pocket Pc Mysteriously...
    Lag down like crazy and shut down? (5)
    For some reason my ppc lagged down until it's even hard to open any programs until the ppc
    itself freezes with no program running. I had to reset the main memory and delete everything. This
    happened twice before and I have no clue what's wrong with it. Have anyone had this similiar
    experience?....
  14. i wish all these losers would shut up
    (5)
    man you guys are a bunch of sorry winy ass babies get a life already.....
  15. Shut Down, Restart, Log Off Xp Using A Batch File
    Undocumented feature for XP (0)
    This is a copy of a tutorial I created for astahost.com. I'm copying it here as a courtesy to
    trap17 members. /smile.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' alt='smile.gif' /> QUOTE
    How to shutdown a XP Pro computer when you are connected using RDC (Remote Desktop Connection)
    using a batch file or RPC (Remote Procedure Command) This is useful if you can't get to the
    computer but have remote access to the computer via a network or the internet. First To show you
    what you will see at a command prompt (command.com) when you type: "shutdown /?" Wit....
  16. Lokitorrent Shut Down
    (11)
    when going to lokitorrent.com you will encounter this QUOTE There are websites that provide
    legal downloads. This is not one of them. This website has been permanently shut down by court
    order because it facilitates the illegal downloading of copyrighted motion pictures. The illegal
    downloading of motion pictures robs thousands of honest, hard-working people of their livelihood,
    and stifles creativity. Illegally downloading movies from sites such as these without proper
    authorization violates the law, is theft, and is not anonymous. Stealing movies leaves a tra....
  17. Both My Shops Shut Down
    :-( (0)
    my zencart shop and my cubecart shop always shut down at the same time. obviously, it's not
    their company's fault. my main site is always up but not my other two. can some one help me on
    dis?....

    1. Looking for 48percent, doctors, admit, prescribing, placebos, shut

Searching Video's for 48percent, doctors, admit, prescribing, placebos, shut
advertisement



48% Of Doctors Admit To Prescribing Placebos Just To Shut You Up



 

 

 

 

ADD REPLY / Got an Opinion! Remove these ADs! RAPID SEARCH! Free Web Hosting [X]
Express your Opinions, Thoughts or Contribute more info. to help others.
Ask your Doubts & Queries to get answers, So that "Together We can help others!"
Register FREE for AD-FREE forum, Create your own topics, Ask Questions, track topics, setup subscriptions & notifications and Get a Free Website w/ Email and FTP.
500MB Space *No Ads*, CPanel, FTP, PHP, MySQL, EMails - 100% FREE