| |   |
|
|
|
|
1st: -not much to criticize... 5/10 2nd: -background and render don't match in color/hue. there is also no blending with the render to the background, which there should be some of at least. -text is large, unblended, and attracts too much eye attention... text usually should complement the sig, matching in color perhaps? and not usually being one of the main focuses. -background is plain... no texture/depth at all, really, try brushing or something? -nice cutting out of the render... if you did that, i always have trouble with hair  -4/10 3rd: -to me, it seems like there is too much text here, going in multiple directions, and the glow effect is a tannish color, not really matching the sig background (which it is on), so it looks kind of weird... -yay! a background, but... a little too repetetive, it seems... boring. colors sort-of matching the render, but not really, it looks darker, and less colorful than the render. -render is thrown on, no blending attempt, and it sticks out too much. -the colors don't seem to match, pehaps a "Layer>New Adjustment Layer> Color Balance" would help? that would get the colors matching more, with a little fiddling around. -5/10 overrall decent, the first is the best, in my opinion. my style in judging is to focus on the bad, because that is what will help you advance, "good job" won't. keep practicing, try different styles, see which one you enjoy doing and are best at. have fun 
Thanks for the advice, I just learned how to blend and I tried to--I didn't 'slap on' the renders at all but maybe I accidently changed it? They don't look the same as when I made them...on the Rascal Flatts the text is supposed to be the main thing it's not really a sig but still I appreciate the criticism.
I like the first one, as it has the effect of a road behind it! really good! keep it up!
Similar Topics
Keywords : sigs rate comment ignore completely
Okay guys, I'm suprised we don't have this here yet, but anyway, we're gonna play a Here you go, I worked really hard on these to make them right /biggrin.gif" This is one of my inferior sigs. I'm currently not on my computer but when I am I will post my ... Well i made one from a stock of Jumper (the film) And i made one from a stock on GuildInn's I have made a collection of sigs /smile.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":)" border="0" Hey I'm pretty new to these forums, but I'm sure I can contribute in some way. Here are some These are my first sigs using PS CS3. Something new to me. Hopeing you guys could give me some Ok I am here to show off my 2 banners i have made. I made one of them a few minutes ago and the Please id like some comments over this sigs . thanks This is a banner for a friends website : Most of these are from Naruto from my Forum but yeah I would like some criticizm and Comments. All right friends....after joining the forum and looking at the competitions and some of the Well, I've been working on two sigs for the SOTW contest. I'm not sure which one to enter These are most sigs I made, please rate them and if anyone wants me to, I'm still making them For my mate Domonic a.k.a The Lone Knight For my rubiks enthusiast Sunny i actually have a PSD copy this time /biggrin.gif' border='0' style='vertical-align:middle' Just a couple of my newer sigs: V1: V2: Well, thats my newest ones Hey guys, I wouldlike to present to you my 2 latest sigs. I have been Gaining sig experience for These are some WoW sigs I cooked up whilst revising for my exams. Could you please tell me how I can Yeah, I suck with GIMP but meh. Messing around with it and creating some sigs. Of course, the sigs Here are a couple of my sigs that i have made:- Won me SOTW on Asylum51.com Well now that we got are 15 member group completed It is time that they get there sigs so lets get Could you please give me advice on this sig and also rate this as well. This was made in fireworks. First signature Second sig Third sig Fourth sig + my favorite Fith sig Matching I'm new to using photoshop so none of this is going to be very good but please comment and reply Please rate and also say whether the writing should be in there or not: How do ya'll like em? I like 'em a lot! They finaly have borders!... Sorry for the long delay guys school stuff happening and of course working on getting CS3 to work Looking for sigs, rate, comment, ignore, completely
|
 -new Sigs- - rate, comment, ignore completely... |
| ADD REPLY / Got an Opinion! | a humble request :-) | RAPID SEARCH! | Free Hosting | [X] |
|
Express your Opinions, Thoughts or Contribute your information that might help someone here. Ask your Doubts & Queries to get answers.. "Together, We enlight each other!" |
Register FREE for AD-FREE forum, Create your own topics, Ask Questions, track topics, setup subscriptions & notifications and Get a Free Website w/ Email and FTP. | 500MB Space *No Ads*, CPanel, FTP, PHP, MySQL, EMails - 100% FREE |
|