Both games have thier high points. It's really difficult to say exactly which one is better, because personally, I own both and I enjoy both.
ESPN did so well on the presentation it was hard to put down. The gameplay was great, it didn't matter if you were using sliders or not, you still got realistic scores ( of course you got really good at one difficulty). Also, the Half-time and Post-game cinemas was great and SportsCenter put it all together. There will probably never be another game like it, it brought so much to the football gaming community, and as a owner of a football gaming site I know this for an unbiased fact. It set alot of standards for EA and EA just decided to take them out instead of coming to par with what ESPN was doing.
Madden, on the other hand is one of the best games of all-time, it's consistent with it's greatness year in and year out. I think Gamespot underates this game, it should at least be an 8.9. The presentation is decent, but it took alot out by not adding for instance the key players at the begining of the game. It's like you play the game, you end the game, time for next week. However Madden having the NFL liscense and ESPN on thier side, they should be able to put together the best Madden of all, fully presentated and gameplay oreiented along with the features such as Training Camp and draft classes. EA has to produce on 07 to maintain it's respectability and with the 360 and PS3 being around by the next launch date, THEY HAVE NO EXCUSE! I demand better presentation, and if they can better DB and WR reality. The graphics won't mean anything unless they fix these on-lasting gameplay problems. This is a matter I feel quite strongly about as a hardcore football gamer. If they can't out-do ESPN in 07 then they should cancel the liscense. I mean how bland is winning the Super Bowl? Goodness! Anyways that's my opinion.
In the end, I would have to say ESPN takes the cake, because it produces in both major catergories football and sports gamers care about. Realism and Presentation.
-DaRealChrono
Reply