Nov 26, 2009

The Debate Over Genetics

free web hosting
Open Discussion > xisT-O-Rama > Life Talk > Debates

The Debate Over Genetics

Striker9
The 20th century has witnessed major advancements in various scientific fields. The achievements that have been made by the world’s brightest scientists and thinkers enormously contributed to the prosperity of the human civilization. Among the most important advancements of the 20th century were those that were accomplished in molecular biology and genetics, such as the applications of genetic engineering and cloning. But the development of such honorable technologies, from a scientific point of view, was accompanied by a furious debate from an ethical one.

Genetics is the branch of biology that deals with heredity, especially the mechanisms of hereditary transmission and the variation of inherited characteristics among similar or related organisms.. This science is considered one of the most recent ones, since the major discoveries and applications were achieved in the last quarter of the 20th century. Those achievements astonished commoners as well as the scientists, because two centuries ago talking about something called “cloning” would be considered insanity and blasphemy.

Genetics as a pure science is something no one could argue against, and everybody would agree that this science grants a badge of honor and pride to everyone who contributed in its development and to the whole human civilization as well. Some scientists, socialists, religious men, and commoners stand against this science and refuse it completely. But others do not find anything wrong about it and have no problem in applying its techniques. Also, others take a midway position and accept some of its applications but at the same time refuse others. Those who refuse this science claim that it is unethical because they believe it is wrong to manipulate human life. Others say it is religiously forbidden because it is a defiance of God’s will and an intervention in His creation. But the fact is those who say that clearly fell into a misconception because genetics did not find a new mean of creation; it is simply discovered God’s secrets allowing us to utilize them. Basically, cloning was a clear answer to scientists’ wondering about whether all cells are capable of producing a complete organism, or is this ability restricted to fertilized zygotes only. Therefore, cloning which involves the insertion of a nucleus into a cytoplasm of any cell proved that reproduction and fertilization have no significant relationship and any cell is capable of producing a complete organism when put in an appropriate medium. Thus this discovery of the secretes of reproduction shall make the belief in God more profound and not the opposite. But let’s be real for a moment; if cloning and genetic engineering techniques weren’t applied on humans, this whole ethical and religious debate wouldn’t have been raised in the first place.

The application of genetic engineering techniques and cloning could avail humans vastly. It could increase and ameliorate plant production by modifying the genome of the plants to produce better strains. Also, cloning of animals could increase meat production and probably save certain animals from extinction. Moreover, cloning can produce human organs that could be utilized when needed, which means these organs would be used as replacement parts in case someone had a damaged or non-functional organ. Furthermore, genetic engineering could help cure some hereditary diseases by locating the gene responsible for the expression of the disease and replacing it with another gene that does not cause the sickness. In addition, this same technique could be used to develop new abilities in humans which would help them resist certain environmental factors or improve human current abilities such as vision, hearing… etc.

On the other hand, genetics has its downsides as well. Those disadvantages – if we can say so – are in general considered from the ethical, religious and humanitarian side. Genetic engineering allows us to modify the genome of the zygote/cell and thus determining all the characteristics of the upcoming embryo, including all the different outer features of a human. This is considered unethical and against God’s will, because it is wrong to intervene in the genetic program of the embryo unless it is for the sake of removing hereditary diseases. Also, let’s consider this hypothetical situation: a cytoplasm is taken from a woman’s bone marrow cell, and then a nucleus from her FATHER’s skin cell is inserted inside this cytoplasm; in this case, the resulting embryo would be produced carrying all the features and characteristics of the nucleus donator (where the genetic program is found) that is the father. Analyzing this hypothetical situation, we’d fall in an extremely unpleasant controversy, because we wouldn’t be able to determine whether the fetus is her father or son! Moreover, abusing the huge capabilities of genetic engineering might lead some insane scientists to do crazy things such as producing genetically mutated animals or even monsters. Similarly, some lunatics might abuse human cloning to create an army of brainwashed clones that serve their interests in probably conquering the planet! The options are diverse, and you can expect anything from people that have no ethics and values with such massive technologies at the reach of their hands – the results could be devastating!

So after this brief demonstration of the pros and cons of genetics and its applications, we need to take a stance towards this controversial issue. It’s clear now that abusing the technologies provided by genetics could lead to destructive and totally unethical consequences, but on the other hand genetics provides us with technologies and applications that could be very beneficial to the whole human race. As a result, we cannot just dump this advanced science into the dumpster just because abusing it could be destructive! Therefore, the logical thing to do is to take benefit of this science as much as it provides and restrict it to scientists and geneticists that are trustworthy and are known for their integrity and ethical principles. But even this wouldn’t be enough because human instincts and love for power could corrupt the most honorable man, thus there must be an international committee that would supervise any genetic experiments or projects according to pure scientific and ethical regulations. In the end, we can ask or wonder whether these huge capabilities of genetic engineering could abolish the word “disease” from our dictionary or even serve to achieve the human dream of immortality?!

 

 

 


Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)

moutonoir
Genetics is indeed a very controversial issue. I found the movie Gattaca very interesting since it presented the idea of being able to choose traits of one's children. This, I believe, is very controversial. It involves allowing humans to decide which traits are acceptable and which are not, and thus would lead to a homogenous society. Is this truly what we want? As technology advances, there is becoming less and less tolerance for indvidual differences. Anyone who does not fit the mold is deemed ill and given whatever treatment would make them like everyone else. This is not necessarily a good thing. It is important to to have a variety of individuals in order to maximize skills and capabilities as a whole. By controlling people's abilities and characteristics through genetics, such variety will most likely be reduced. Those who are different will face an even greater challenge since they will be in a much smaller minority, and people will wonder why their parents didn't choose more normal genes for them.

Another issue involvong genetics concerns stem cell research, since the embryos used to produce the stem cells end up dying. To some, this is akin to abortion, and they do not support stem cell research. I disagree with this view. Most often, these embryos would not have been allowed to grow into human babies anyway; their sole purpose was to be used for research. By not going forward with such research, people who are currently suffering from severe illnesses are left to continue suffering when there could be treatment for them. By saving the "lives" of these embryos, others lives are being lost.

Luckily, it looks like there may be a way to continue with this research without the cost of embryos. Recently, a scientist has found a way to get stem stems from adult cells. This would be wonderful if it proved to work; the controversy mentioned before would be minimized and new treatments could be available for those in need. NOVA did a story on this: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/sciencenow/0305/03.html

There are many ethical issues to consider in the field of genetics. Ultimately, it comes down to the idea that humans are trying to play "god" and become more powerful than nature intended us to be. It will be interesting to see how this technology evolves over the next few decades, and how we deal with it.

 

 

 


Comment/Reply (w/o sign-up)



Got an Opinion! Express your Views! (no registration):-
Add your Reply/ Opinion/ Views/ Comments/ Suggestion/ Questions/ Queries etc.
Posts with decent grammar & English will be accepted and please refrain from profanities.
For asking a Question, We recommend you to sign-up (for free) so that you can track the topic easily.

Nature of your Post*: Opinion/ Reply/ Comments
Question/Query
Feedback to us.
       
Name   Email
Title/Question*

This textarea will convert to Rich-Text automatically (IE, Firefox, Chrome)

Similar Topics

Keywords : debate, genetics

  1. Stress From Racism May Be Factor In High Black Infant Deaths - The Debate Hospital Racism
    (1)
  2. 2008 Presidential Debates
    How important was this first debate and how did McCain and Obama do? (7)
    I watched the first in the series of Presidential Debates that the John McCain and Barack Obama are
    engaging in. This first one was supposed to be primarily on foreign policy but half of it ended up
    being on the 700 billion dollar bank bail-out and on how each presidential hopeful will get the
    great country of the USA out of its current economic crisis. I feel that John McCain was slightly
    drowned out by Obama concerning the passion and clarity of their speeches. However, I also feel
    that McCain backed up his opinions better than Obama did by bringing scenarios in the p....
  3. Fresh Water Should Be Common Property: My Own Debate Theses
    (4)
    These are the theses of the karl-popper debate me and my team made a year ago. Please rate them as
    it is important to us /smile.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":)" border="0"
    alt="smile.gif" />. Thank you! QUOTE Affirmative theses Resolution: Private management of
    fresh water utilities is preferable o their public management. Definitions Fresh water can be
    defined as water with less than 0.5 parts per thousand dissolved salts. Freshwater bodies include
    lakes, rivers, and some bodies of underground water. The ultimate source of fresh water is the prec....
  4. A Debate On Animal Testing
    (40)
    I thought I should make this debate a bit more different: If you are for animal testing post in
    blue If you are against animal testing, post in red Context: For many centuries people
    have experimented on animals. There are two main reasons for doing this: first, to find out more
    about the animals themselves, and, secondly, to test substances and procedures to see if they are
    harmful (with a view to deciding whether or not they can be used on human beings). In the second
    category fall cosmetic products as well as medicines and surgical techniques. There i....
  5. The Big Debate On Cloning
    Just something i think... (11)
    Hey guys i just wanted to share my thoughts on cloning with you.... so here goes: Cloning, genetic
    engineering, and other forms of biotechnology are fast advancing, and there's no denying it.
    The question is: Is this advance good for the human race, or is it bad? Cloning of humans is
    seriously unethical and immoral and should be addressed soon because of its grave consequences.
    Opposing cloning takes sophisticated knowledge and a mature mind to look past the big: It can save
    lives excuse. The dilemma with cloning is not how many lives it can save, but how many li....
  6. What Is Your Favorite Color?
    debate what your favorite color is and why (30)
    in this debate you should explain what your favorite color is and why it is that color over all
    other colors. ill start it off and say my favorite color is a dark green an this is my favorite
    color because i like camping/hunting and other outdoor activities and most of the trees have dark
    green leaves so that became my favorite color....
  7. Should Languages Be Required For College Programs?
    Debate it here (9)
    When I went to college, I was fortunate enough to be able to not take a foreign language class in
    college because I passed my placement exam for Spanish. But what happens if you didn't pass? I
    know many people who haven't passed and are later required to take that foreign language during
    college (not all programs require this, but some do). Many people that are studying these languages
    are protesting and claiming that it is a waste of time. Many people claim that it is useless. After
    all, isn't college supposed to "prepare" you for your future career? What i....
  8. Turkey In The Eu: Yes Or No?
    Debate on whether Turkey's entry petition in the EU should be acce (13)
    Turkey's entry in the EU has been postponed for the time being, and is said to be reconsidered
    in a few years time. As it is a matter that I consider of great importance, I would like to know
    what the opinion of most people here is on the subject. There are many pros and cons to the issue.
    Turkey is a large country of 72 million people and a demographical wonder for its size (with the
    media age being 28.1, see http://worldfacts.us/Turkey.htm ). It is an economically developing
    country, and can contribute greatly to the European median age as well, provide a good s....
  9. Democracy
    in Australia. A debate (3)
    Democracy is good according to many influential people, but at times personally I have never felt
    like I am in a democracy. What are my options? A Coalition government that can be anti-labour one
    day, and then look like they may pro-labour stance the next. The federal Labour party that seem to
    be in the middle, but have they got a clear policy!?! Oh and the slow but gradual decline of the
    democrat influence in the senate which apparently was meant "to keep the *BLEEP*s honest". I fall
    somewhere between middle class and lower class, also am a p/t uni student and get hit ....
  10. Religion And Terrorism
    Debate (14)
    Starting off, to be quite honest, I'm so sick to death about hearing about terrorist attacks
    occuring overseas. For example, a recent one was reported on tv that authorities had arrested 20
    muslims. Before some people go on about how this religion is bad, and what they are doing is wrong,
    and so forth, pretty much every religion has their type of weirdos and crackheads. In many cases,
    religion is not what fuels the fire, its those that are really greedy within the ranks, you got
    hitler and his dislike for jews, the czaars in Russia, and so forth. It seems that man....
  11. HTML COPYRIGHT
    this is the biggest debate want opinions (12)
    ok i would believe this would be the biggest topic of all time where does the copyrights for any
    scripting excluding software start and were does it end. its amazing how people can say their html
    is copyrighted when a few million designers use the same thing, pictures understandale but not html,
    cgi, javascript, php, asp and all those other scripting related things. yeah starting webdesign i
    took some ideas or plane out copyed the whole page just to get a understanding of it but still.. oh
    i could swing it the whole other way and say i might be wrong and its www proto....

    1. Looking for debate, genetics

Searching Video's for debate, genetics
See Also,
advertisement


The Debate Over Genetics

Affordable Web Hosting, Low cost Web Hosting - ComputingHost.com